Click Bait, Cancel Culture & The Rhetoric of Civic Discourse

Published on Feb 19, 2020

No Description

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

Click Bait, Cancel Culture

and the Rhetoric of Civic Discourse

Overview

  • Origins of Rhetoric
  • Teaching Philosophy
  • Definitions
  • Examples
  • Implications
Photo by ROBIN WORRALL

Dr. Jeannie Parker Beard

PhD in Rhetoric & Composition: Multimodal Composition

Rhetoric?

  • The Art of Persuasion
  • Participant Democracy
  • Civic Engagement
  • Freedom

Untitled Slide

Composing on the Screen

Student Perceptions of Traditional & Multimodal Composition 

Teaching Philosophy

  • Critical Thinking
  • Empowerment
  • Diversity of Thought
  • Intellectual Integrity
  • Facilitation
  • HEART
Photo by sure2talk

Civic Discourse

Aristotle's On Rhetoric 

ClickBait

Fact or Fiction? Both?
Photo by Mael BALLAND

Mainstream vs Social Media

Tech Giants & Corporate Control

Untitled Slide

Photo by 401(K) 2013

Untitled Slide

Cancel Culture

Photo by mag3737

Twitter

Big Fish, Little Fish

What is really at stake?

Untitled Slide

NYT

The Making of a YouTube Radical

Untitled Slide

YouTube

The Death of The People's Platform 
Photo by swisscan

Where are we now?

  • New Public Square
  • Lack of Inhibition
  • Filter Bubbles
  • Anxiety
  • FOMO
  • Bandwagon Mentality
  • Mob Rule
  • Polarization
Photo by rhett maxwell

Effects of clickbait & Cancel Culture

  • Hyperbolic perceptions of reality
  • False sense of understanding
  • Increased Isolation & Division
  • Lack of Discourse
  • Acceptance of Intolerance
  • Loss of Freedom
  • Loss of Diversity of Thought
  • Corporate Control
Photo by blende74.de

it's Okay to Disagree

  • Culture War
  • Personalities Differ
  • Information Literacy
  • The Power of Rhetoric
  • Intellectual Responsibility
  • Debate = Democracy
The whole point of studying rhetoric is to be better equipped to participate in the democratic process. The very discipline was created out of the notion of citizen participation, despite the inclination of the early philosophers to think that the general public is too daft to adequately function in a democratic society. Though it is true that the ancient Greeks did not exist in an entirely free society, it was the first on record in the West to conceive of a function for civic discourse, a literal forum where the independent and free citizens of the city state could speak in public and persuade the masses to vote on matters of public import. There is no need for total consensus in a democratic system, in fact, 100% consensus is contrary to the very ideals of freedom. If everyone was to agree on every issue, there would be no need to vote on anything, and indeed, it is questionable that even in such a idealistic environment, that every individual would agree 100% of the time with the masses. In such an envrionment of mandatory consensus, even the independent thinker would feel the immense pressure of speaking out against the group for fear of ostracization, excommunication, or worse, prosecution and if not literal death then social death. Diversity of thought is a healthy fucntion of civic discourse. There can be no other way for there would be no need for civic discourse or a theory thereof if we all existed as automatons with the same ideals and conceptions. Lack of discourse, or diversity of thought and opinion, is mental slaverly, and it is dangerous, censorious, and against the principles of free society. Sensational headlines generated to cultivate the mob mentality, curate profits, and circumvent competition does not make a just society, but quite the opposite. A stifling of open debate and intelligent, measured argumentation creates a fearful society where people may pretend to be on the bandwagon in the public sphere for fear of ostracization or isolation, but in private they feel the burden of oppression and tyranny. When people can be canceled for differing opinions, a toxic environment is created, one of oppression, suppression, and false consensus.

Untitled Slide

Rhetoric

The Road to Civic Discourse, Civility, & Sanity
Photo by Tyler Nix

Untitled Slide

Jeannie Beard

Haiku Deck Public User