Contrast to Functionalists - Functionalists think low level deviance = good, maintains social order and unifies society, benefitting everyone. WHEREAS Marxists say social control is to prevent rebellion & revolution as capitalism is exploitative. Social control benefits the working class.
AQA A Level Sociology: overview of the links between Marxist perspectives on society and their views of the role of/reasons for crime and deviance within society. Appropriate for Yr 2 of the specification, covering the Crime and Deviance unit.
Contrast to Functionalists - Functionalists think low level deviance = good, maintains social order and unifies society, benefitting everyone. WHEREAS Marxists say social control is to prevent rebellion & revolution as capitalism is exploitative. Social control benefits the working class.
Exploitation of the proletariat: capitalism works due to exploitation, leading to poverty which can cause crime through a need to pay bills or frustration at their situation leading to violence (think about links to Cohen and status frustration).
Values of capitalism: desire to make money leads to criminal behaviour in the ruling class (fraud, blackmail)
Who makes the law? Functionalists would say it's a reflection of the will of the people, Marxists would say it reflects ruling-class interests as it's made by the ruling-class.
Most law deals with property and protection of property.
Chambliss & Mankoff (1976) law keeps working-class away from property Snider (1993) regulation on large companies is limited Pearce (1976) 'protection' laws really protect ruling classes
Gordon (1976) - selective enforcement and reporting as diversion Chambliss (1978) - those in power could conduct crime and avoid prison Snider (1993) - corporate crime does more harm than 'working-class' crime e.g. burglary
Taylor, Walton & Young (1973) crime = choice New criminology = looking at all aspects of the crime - aiming to understand rather than remove deviant behaviour. Crime is conscious; meaningful; deliberate - aims to change society; Black Panther Movement; Robin Hood
Hall: 'Policing the Crisis' = moral panic around mugging.
Links to other theories/explanations?
Gilroy - 1982 'myth of black criminality' labelling process.
Crime as a political act? Focus of the gov. Distract from unsolved problems.