The first shark attack happened on July 2, 1916. The second shark attack happened on July 7, 1916. The third shark attack happened at the New Jersey Creek on July 13, 1916.
In the shark attacks, 4 people were killed. Charles Vansant and Charles Bruder were fatally wounded. 11 year old Lester Stillwell was killed while swimming in Matawan Creek. Stanley Fisher was attacked while trying to rescue Lester. 12 year old Joseph Dunn was bitten on the leg but survived.