"I know, but what did I say?" "I'm sure it seems that way"
Do not attempt to think- Stay "Brain Dead"
If they continue...give em options
Don't argue with the students, give them the one liner.
Don't argue with students, give them a one liner: More examples: "Probably so." "I know." "Nice try." "I bet it feels that way." "What do you think you're going to do." "I don't know. What do you think?" "Bummer. How sad." "Thanks for sharing that." "Don't worry about it now." "That's an option." "I bet that's true." "Maybe you'll like what we have for the next meal better." "What do you think I think about that?" "I'm not sure how to react to that. I'll have to get back to you on it." "I'll let you know what will work for me." "I'll love you wherever you live."
Remind yourself by setting up sticky notes to remind yourself of these limits and enforceable statements. This puts the responsibility on the students, not you.
Instead of "Stop talking" try saying "I will begin when it is quiet"