A. State Issue: Is it ethical for religious views of government incumbents to influence their decision to ban same-sex marriage? B. What kind of Issue: This is a politically and religiously associated issue that affects same-sex couples. C. Boundaries: Restriction of same-sex marriages affects same-sex couples in their personal lives and economically on state and federal levels.
D. Side A: Some feel it is unethical for religious views of government incumbents to influence their decision to ban same-sex marriage. The U.S. Constitution requires the separation of church and state in order to provide all its citizens with equal religious and political freedom, however, taking an objective stance on the topic of same-sex marriage is difficult for incumbents given their religious associations. E. Side B: Others believe religious views of government incumbents naturally affect their decision to ban same-sex marriages, because as citizens of the U.S. they have the right to their own religious beliefs and the right to practice those beliefs without government interference.