Begin with a discussion of your response paper. What was your response paper about? What trouble did you have?

Peer Review

• Is there an argument?
• Is there a thesis?  Underline it if you see one.
• Is there support? (Quotes from text, summary)
• After support, is there analysis?
• What could they do to further analysis?

Pick a response paper that the group agrees has good analysis. Give a brief summary of paper, and pose a discussion question to talk about with the rest of the class.